A while ago, I was granted refugee status in the UK on the basis of my homosexuality and my political activities in Iran. As a person who has shared the same stress of being a gay asylum seeker in the UK with lots of other applicants, I was happy yesterday to hear that the coalition agreement between the Tories and the Lib Dems included a promise to "stop the deportation of asylum seekers who have had to leave particular countries because their sexual orientation or gender identification puts them at proven risk of imprisonment, torture or execution".
Not everybody is as lucky as I was in seeking asylum in the United Kingdom. Within a month after my asylum interview with the Home Office I had the positive decision in my hand, partly because I had a huge international support and also partly because my application was mostly based on my political activities rather than my homosexuality. This is why I was given "the refugee status" rather than "a humanitarian protection". The first one is the strongest but it's the latter that is given to gay asylum seekers in almost all of the cases.
The Home Office's attitude toward gay asylum seekers in the UK has been very controversial in recent years. It is said that the UK protects those homosexuals who have well-founded fear of persecution were they to return to their home countries but arbitrary decisions have been made, too. In regards to Iran, although its notorious record of executing homosexuals is very well documented by international human rights organisations, large numbers of gay Iranian cases have been turned down every year.
Recently, a new report on the treatment of lesbian and gay asylum claims in the UK found that the refusal rate was 90%, compared with 73% for all the claims generally. In two recent Iranian cases, one applicant, known as "J" had to go to appeals court after his claim was refused.
Most surprisingly, the asylum application for Kiana Firouz, a lesbian Iranian actress who has been courageously public about her homosexuality, was turned down. Kiana Firouz is depicted in Cul-de-Sac, a documentary about Iranian lesbians which had its debut in London yesterday. In the film, she says: "In Iran I had to hide my real self and in the UK, I have to prove to the others that I'm lesbian but how can I prove it?"
Of course, it's hard for officials to verify someone's homosexuality, and some have expressed concern that fake claims are likely to be made. But in my opinion the risks to genuine asylum seekers outweighs the potential for abuse.
Back to my case, I again had an exceptional circumstance. I had my partner with me in London and we claimed together. The Home Office interviewed both of us separately at the same time for six hours and finally they had some sort of evidence to investigate and find out whether we have been together in a long relationship or not. We were both asked about the first day we had kissed, whether we used to celebrate Valentine's Day and whether either of us used to keep pets at home. However, most of the asylum seekers in the UK are not accompanied with their partners.
In the case of Iran, overt homosexuality is illegal. Gay Iranians can be lashed, hanged or stoned to death if caught. The law includes a variety of penalties for different acts: 99 lashes if two unrelated males sleep "unnecessarily" under the same blanket – even without any sexual contact. An immature boy raped by an adult man would also be lashed 74 times according to the same law, if the court decided that he had "enjoyed" the experience. Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch have also documented the persecution of homosexuals in Iran.
The Boroumand Foundation, a US-based Iranian human rights organisation, has also recorded 146 executions with charges related to homosexuality since 1979. In 1991, in its reply to inquiries made by a UN special representative, the Iranian government stated that "according to the Islamic Sharia, homosexuals who confess to their acts and insist on [their homosexuality] are condemned to death".
However, since Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's disgraceful denial of the existence of homosexuals in Iran in his 2007 Columbia University Q&A, the Iranian gay community has won some recognition underground, despite the great danger of execution. The number of gay blogs in Iran has surprisingly increased since then, internet-based gay novels and magazines have been published and recently Radiozamaneh.com, an Iranian radio website based in the Netherlands, has launched a special gay forum. Cul-de-Sac The premiere of Cul-de-Sac yesterday was also a remarkable move.
Britain, for a long period, has been appreciated for its tradition of granting asylum to those in danger from the governments of their home counties. It's the right time for the Home Office not only to protect those homosexuals who have well-founded fear of persecution but also to put an end to the detention of the children and families of asylum seekers. The coalition government should immediately fulfil its promises and protect those vulnerable asylum seekers who are in risk of being deported. Most importantly, we shouldn't forget that asylum is a human right.
Iranian Minorities Human Right Organisation
IMHRO started in January 2008. We are a NGO based in the UK and are independent from governments and political parties. We campaign for the Human Rights of Ethnic, Religious, Gender and Sexual Minorities in Iran.
For any enquiry and adding your name to our E-mail list, please contact us:
Jasem Heidari (L), Ali Heidari and Abdul Rahman Heidari (R) are three out of five members of Iran’s Ahwazi Arab minority who were executed after being convicted of “enmity against God.
Sherko Moarefi, the 31-year-old Iranian Kurdish activist who is facing imminent execution on a charge of 'enmity with God'
Habibollah Latifi, a Kurdish Student sentenced to execution By Iranian Security Service, his trial was behind closed doors and without lawyer.
A 28 years old, Kurdish woman Zainab Jalalian sentenced to death by revolutionary court in Iran. she did not had access to a lawyer since she was arrested in 2008 in the bus search in Kermanshah.
Jews: Babak Tehrani (Pic in his Mothers hand): 12 Persian Jews who were kidnapped by the Iranian secret police between 1994 and 1997 and have not been heard from since.
Mohammad Hassan Falahieh, an Ahwazi Arab Journalist and Broadcaster is in prison for reporting bad Living conditions of Ahwazi Arabs
7 Bahá’í leader, the religious minority, arrested by security forces in Iran. Iranian government accused them of working for Israel. they sentenced to 20-year jail.
Three American hikers Shane Bauer, Sarah Shourd and Joshua Fattal, were arrested on Friday, July 31, 2009 kidnaped in Iraq-Iran Border. they kept in inhuman condition and subjected to torture.
Iranian revolutionary court, branch 15 in Tehran has sentenced Mr. Mohammad Sadigh Kabodwand, founder of the Kurdish Human Rights Centre to 11 years in prison
A 22 years old, pregnant woman executed in Iran
Silva Harotonian, an Iranian-Armenian IREX employee who has been sentenced to three years in prison
Hiwa Butimar, a Kurdish Journalist and Environmental activist, for second times, sentenced to death
Farzad Kamngar a Kurdish teacher and environmental campaigner Executed in 2010
Iranian government sentenced Yusef Azizi Bani Turfi, a prominent Ahwazi Arab writer and author of several books, to five years in prison after he criticised the government’s heavy handling of peaceful demonstration in Arabic area of al Ahwaz in April 2005.
police and special elite Revolutionary Guard forces stormed the Muslim Sufi lodge, Some 80 people were injured
Poverty in Baluchistan: Iranian government deliberately not investing in Baluchistan as they are mainly Sunni
American citizen Bob Levinson went missing on March 2007 in Kish Island and Iranian government denying he is arrested or having any information about him.
Sunni mosque Bulldozered by Iranian government in Baluchistan
Mahmoud Asgari and Ayaz Marhoni, 14 and 16 years old Gay Executed in Iran
28-year-old Tina Rad, who converted to Christianity from Islam had tortured by Security police
An Iranian Christian couple,Abbas Amiri and Sakineh Rahnama, in their 60s died last week from injuries sustained when secret police raided a house church service hosted at their house and severely beat them
Yaghub Mehrnahad, a Baluchi human Right Activist, after a secret trial, executed in August 2008
Farhad Mohseni Negarestan, 25 year old Turk, had killed under torture while he was interrogated by Iranian intelligence service
Kaveh Aziz Poor, a Kurdish man who was from a village near Mahabad city, lost consciousness under torture and after 20 days died in hospital in the city of Uromiyeh
Zamel Bavi 29 year old, an Ahwazi Arab, executed after a year in solitary confinement and torture
List of major Religious, Ethnic and LGBT Minorities in Iran
John Peters Humphrey: The father of the modern human rights system
Peace can only last where human rights are respected, where the people are fed, and where individuals and nations are free
Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere
Give peace a chance.
As we are liberated from our own fear, our presence automatically liberates others
Silence in the face of injustice is complicity with the oppressor. Ginetta Sagan
An eye for an eye makes the whole world blind
We must reject the false comfort that other’s suffering is not our problem
Only when the last prisoner of conscience has been freed, when the last torture chamber has been closed, when the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights is a reality for the world's people, will our work be done